"ThetwoMcCarthyswereseeimewhenWilliamCrame-keeper,lostsightofthem。TheBosbePoolisthicklywoodedround,withjustafringeofgrassandofreedsroundtheedge。Agirloffourteen,Patien,whoisthedaughterofthelodge-keeperoftheBosbeValleyestate,wasihewoodspigflowers。Shestatesthatwhileshewasthereshesaw,attheborderofthewoodahelake,MrMdhisson,andthattheyappearedtobehaviquarrel。SheheardMrMcCarthytheelderusironglaohissohelatterraiseuphishandasiftostrikehisfather。ShewasshteheirviolesheranawayaherwhenshereaethatshehadleftthetwoMcCarthysquarrellingnearBosbePool,andthatshewasafraidthattheyweregoingtofight。ShehadhardlysaidthewordswhenyoungMrMcCarthyinguptothelodgetosaythathehadfoundhisfatherdeadinthewood,andtoaskforthehelpofthelodge-keeper。Hewasmuchexcited,withunorhishat,andhisrighthandandsleevewereobservedtobestaihfreshblood。Onfollowihedeadbodystretchedoutuponthegrassbesidethepool。Theheadhadbeeeedblowsofsomeheavyandbluheinjuriesweresuchasmightverywellhavebeehebutt-endofhisson'sgun,whichwasfoundlyingonthegrassacesofthebody。Uaheyoungmanwasinstaed,aof'wilfulmurder'havitheiuesday,hewasonWednesdaybroughtbefistratesatRoss,whohavereferredthecasetotheAssizes。Thosearethemainfactsofthecaseastheycameoutbeforethedthepolice-court。"
"Icineamarked。"Ifevertialevideoaalitdoessohere。"
"tialevidenceisaverytrig,"answeredHolmesthoughtfully。"Itmayseemtophttoohing,butifyoushiftyourownpoile,youmayfinditpointinginanequallyunaosomethiirelydifferent。Itmustbefessed,however,thatthecaselooksexglygraveagainsttheyoungman,anditisverypossiblethatheisi。Thereareseveralpeopleintheneighbourhood,however,andamoureroftheneighblandowner,whobelieveinhisinnodwhohaveretairade,whomyoumayrewiththeStudyioworkoutthehisirade,beingratherpuzzled,hasreferredthee,ahattwomiddle-agedgentlemenareflyififtymilesanhourinsteadofquietlydigestingtheirbreakfastsathome。"
"Iamafraid,"saidI,"thatthefactsaresoobviousthatyouwillfiobegaiofthiscase。"
"Thereisnothihananobviousfact,"heanswered,laughing。"Besides,wemaycetohitupoherobviousfactswhichmayhavebeenbynomeansobvioustoMrLestrade。YoukoowelltothinkthatIamboastihatIshalleitherordestroyhistheorybymeanswhichheisquiteinploying,oreveandihefirstexampletohand,Iveryclearlyperceivethatihewindowisupht-haIquestioradewouldhavenotedevensoself-evidentathingasthat。"
"Howoh?"
"Mydearfelloell。Ikarynesswhichcharacterisesyou。Youshaveeverym,andinthisseasonyoushavebythesunlight;butsinceyislessandlesspleteaswegetfartherbatheleftside,untilitbeespositivelysloveroundtheahejaw,itissurelyveryclearthatthatsideislessillumiheother。Iagineamanofyourhabitslookingathimselfinanequallightaisfiedwithsucharesult。Iohisasatrivialexampleofobservatiohereiier,anditisjustpossiblethatitmaybeofsomeservitheiionwhichliesbeforeus。Thereareowominorpointswhichwerebroughtouti,andwhichareworthg。"
"Whatarethey?"
"ItappearsthathisarrestdidoerthereturntoHatherleyFarm。Oorofstabularyinfhimthatherisohathewasnotsurprisedtohearit,andthatitwashahisobservationofhishadtheanytracesofdoubtwhichmighthaveremaihemindsoftheer'sjury。"
"Itwasa,"Iejaculated。
"No,foritwasfollorotestationofi;
"iopofsuingseriesofevents,itwasatleastamostsuspiark。"
"Orary,"saidHolmes,"itisthebrightestriftreseheclouds。Howeveribe,heotbesubeottoseethattheceswereveryblasthim。Hadheappearedsurprisedathisow,nedindignationatit,Ishouldhavelookeduponitashighlysuspicious,becausesuchsurpriseerwoulduraluandyetmightappeartobethebestpoliingman。Hisfraaionmarkshimaseitheraman,orelseasamanofsiderableself-restraintaohisremarkabouthisdeserts,itwasalsonotunnaturalifyousiderthathestoodbesidethedeadbodyofhisfather,andthatthereisnodoubtthathehadthatverydaysottenhisfilialdutyastobandywordswithhim,andeven,agtothelittlegirlwhoseevidenportant,toraisehishandasiftostrikehim。Theself-reproatritionlayedinhisremarkappeartometobethesighymihanofaguiltyo;
Ishookmyhead。"Manymenhavebeenhangedhterevide;Iremarked。
"Sotheyhave。Andmanymenhavebeenwrongfullyha;
"Whatistheyoungman'sownaatter?"
"Itis,Iamafraid,notveryengtohissupphthereareowopointsinitwhicharesuggestive。Youwillfindithere,aforyourself。"
HepihisbundleacopyofthelocalHerefordshirepaper,andhavihesheethepoiheparagraphinwhifortunateyoungmanhadgivenhisowofwhathadoccurred。Isettledmyselfdownintheereaverycarefully。Itraninthis>
"MrJamesMcCarthy,theonlysonofthedeceased,wasthendgaveevidenceasfollows:'IhadbeenawayfromhomeforthreedaysatBristol,andhadonlyjustreturhemoflastMonday,the3rd。Myfatherwasabsentfromhomeatthetimeofmyarrival,andIwasihemaidthathehaddriveoRosswithJohnCobb,thegroom。Shortlyaftermyreturhewheelsofhistrapintheyard,and,lookingoutofmyhimgetoutandidlyouthIhichdirehewasgoiookmygunaiionoftheBosbePool,withtheiionofvisitiwarrenwhitheotherside。OnmyilliamCrame-keeper,ashehadstatedinhisevideakeninthinkingthatIwasfollowingmyfather。Ihadhewasinfrontofme。WhenaboutahundredyardsfromthepoolIheardacryof"Cooee!"whichwasausualsigherahenhurriedforward,andfoundhimstandingbythepool。HeappearedtobemuchsurprisedatseeingmeaherroughlywhatIwasdoingthere。Aversationensuedwhichledtohighwordsandalmosttoblows,formyfatherwasamanofaveryviolenttemper。SeeingthathispassionwasbeingungoverhimaowardsHatherleyFarm。Ihadhan150yards,however,whenIheardahideousoutdme,whichcausedmetorunba。Ifoundmyfatherexpiringupontheground,withhisheadterriblyinjured。Idroppedmygunandheldhiminmyarms,buthealmostinstantlyexpired。IkbesidehimforsomemiheoMrTurner'slodge-keeper,hishousebeioaskforassistanooherwheurned,andIhavenoideahowhecamebyhisiapopularman,beidfinhismahehad,asfarasIknow,noaemies。Iknownothihematter。
"Theer:Didyourfathermakeaoyoubeforehedied?"
"Witness:Hemumbledafewwords,butIlyeallusiontoarat。"
"Theer:Whatdidyouuandbythat?"
"Witomeahoughtthathewasdelirious。"
"Theer:ointuponwhidyourfatherhadthisfinalquarrel?
"Witness:Ishouldprefernottoa;
"TheafraidthatImustpressit。"
"Witisreallyimpossibleformetotellyou。Iassureyouthatithasnothingtodowiththesadtragedywhichfollowed。
"Theer:Thatisforthecourttodeeednotpointouttoyouthatyourrefusaltoanswerwillprejudiceyoursiderablyinanyfutureprogswhichmayarise。
"Witstillrefuse。"
"Theer:Iuhatthecryof'Cooee'wasaonsigweenyouandyourfather?"
"Witwas。"
"Theer:Howwasit,theereditbeforehesawyou,andbeforeheeveyouhadreturnedfromBristol?
"Withsiderable):Idonotknow。"